On the surface, the idea of building a 106-minute movie around a mostly silent man, played by Robert Redford, who's lost at sea seems risky. Or, as writer-director J.C. Chandor puts it, the idea of setting out to write a wordless movie is "not a very smart choice from a business perspective." Yet here's "All is Lost." Chandor's new film has received rave reviews on the film festival circuit (it premiered at the Cannes Film Festival in May and bowed for U.S. audiences at the New York Film Festival this month), and is currently sporting a stellar 95-percent "fresh" rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Redford, meanwhile, is being hailed as doing some of his best work in the last 20 years.


In "All is Lost," Redford, now 77, plays an unnamed man who is stranded in the middle of the Indian Ocean with limited supplies and a slowly sinking boat that was damaged after being hit by a stray shipping container. As mentioned, Redford is alone -- so there's little dialogue and, save for a brief opening scene, no voiceover. This is about as intimate as a movie can get.


What's interesting about "All Is Lost," beyond that premise, has been viewers' reactions to the film's ending. Chandor -- who last wrote and directed the financial crisis drama "Margin Call," for which he received a Best Original Screenplay Oscar nomination -- has some detailed thoughts on the water-cooler chatter, and he got into them in our interview before the film's Oct. 18 release. (That specific discussion is preceded by a heavy spoiler warning.)


You should be happy, people seem to love your movie.

[Laughs] Not everybody; trust me. I'm crazy enough that I've isolated the five or six people who don't like it.


Why do you do that to yourself?

I don't know. My wife asked me the same question.


Of those five or six bad reviews, what point do they make that you'd like to dispute?

There are two things, I think. One is the ending where some people, I think, don't realize that audiences are reacting to the ending very differently. So, they think it's very basic. They say, "Oh, he sold out on the ending." So, that tweaks me a little bit because we fought very hard with our distributor to sort of protect an ending that wasn't just one thing and wasn't maybe what you just thought it would be. And then the other -- and this is always the problem with any review -- is just when the movie isn't for someone, they usually just shut down. Certainly it's always a little bit frustrating when there actually is information in the film that you've put in there and tried to do it in an interesting and subtle way. And you could tell they sort of weren't paying attention -- so they just kind of missed it. But, you know, in the greater scheme of things ... I'm pretty darn happy. You wrote the "50 Dollar Cab Ride" thing, right?


I did. Referencing "Michael Clayton."

For "Margin Call," that was one of my bellwether films. I love that film.


[NOTE: The following exchange contains spoilers about the ending of "All is Lost."]


Without saying what the ending is, it sounds like I'm off base that I interpreted it at face value, because there's nothing else in the movie that wasn't at face value.

Yeah, and that's totally ... what I had intended was, essentially, at that point in the film, when the film immediately ends, it's sort of your ending. But it really does come down to about 50/50 ... there's a huge percentage of the population that can see that has seen the film so far that think, essentially, it's sort of a delusion. That the boat isn't there and that he is essentially ascending. You know, that's the hand of God that reaches down. So, we're trying to keep it as quiet, for now, as possible so that people get to have their own ending. So, wait, you think he was saved, right?


Yes, but I took it into consideration that might not be what's going on ...

Are you a religious guy? Are you an Atheist? Are you a spiritual person?


I'll take the cheap way out and say I'm Agnostic.

[Laughs] Right.


But this isn't "Life of Pi." There are no dream sequences leading up to that scene, so why would there be one in the last scene?

But it is a departure, absolutely -- if that was the case. I sort of haven't been chiming in too much about it ... it's all been pretty good, hopefully people will get off their tushes and see the movie in the next couple of weeks -- because it's definitely meant to be seen in a movie theater.


[End of spoilers]


You need to be invested in the movie, which is harder to do at home.

I thought it would be a neat idea if we maybe just didn't send out screeners and we kind of put all of your resources into holding screenings. And the distributor was like, "Well, you could do that, but you won't get any nominations. It won't even have a chance of getting any nominations. No one in the Academy will see it." Which is sort of a sad state of the business, but it certainly is a far more effective film being seen in a theater.


After "Margin Call," where there's a lot of explaining of what's going on, did you just need to write a movie where no one says anything?

[Laughs] It's not like a literally set out, "I'm going to write a wordless movie." Because that certainly is not a very smart choice from a business perspective. But it did happen ... and the next thing you know you have Robert Redford saying "yes" and then you're about to be on a set in Mexico. And it's sort of like, "Wait, how did I get into this mess?"


While shooting did you ever have doubts like, I'm just filming Robert Redford walking around on a boat?

[Laughs] Once you get int the trenches filming, you kind of delude yourself into thinking a lot of things -- that it's going to work -- but the edit was a challenge. I shouldn't say that -- we edited while we shot and I did start to get confident. I felt like we were on the right track. I really did. And there's so much hell going on while shooting, I sort of refused myself to second guess that and I didn't worry about it because we were so in it.


Your next film, "A Most Violent Year," has been in the news for some of the casting, but I don't really know what it's about.

I know and it's totally premature, that casting news. Not that those people may not end up in the movie.


What is it about?

It's set in 1981 in New York City, which actually is the most violent year on record. And it's a period film about sort of midsize business people and there's a bunch of conflict. But, the casting that's out there right now...


Which we've heard are Jessica Chastain and Javier Bardem...

Yeah. And a couple of other people. That didn't come from us. But, you know, it's really exciting and I've been working on it for awhile and we're probably going to shoot it in, I would think, mid-winter to late winter this year. It's all teed up and financed and ready to go.


Mike Ryan is senior writer for Huffington Post Entertainment. You can contact him directly on Twitter.



Loading Slideshow...



  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Kourtney Kardashian rocked short shorts as she took Penelope to a Mommy & Me class in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 16.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Ashley Benson rocked torn up jeans while out and about in Santa Monica, Calif., on Oct. 16.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Nicole Scherzinger visited "Celeb Juice" in London on Oct. 16.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Eva Longoria grabbed some coffee in Hollywood, Calif., on Oct. 16.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    "Homeland" star Damian Lewis and his wife Helen McCrory arrived at the Service to Celebrate the Harvest for the British Food Fortnight at Westminster Abbey in London on Oct. 16.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Carey Mulligan attended the screening of "Inside Llewyn Davis" during the 57th BFI London Film Festival at Odeon Leicester Square on Oct. 15 in London.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Elijah Wood attended a photocall with Producers Adrian Guerra and Rodrigo Cortes and director Eugenio Mira for "Grand Piano" at Telefonica Gran Via Store in Madrid on Oct. 15.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Cher looked glamorous in embellished sunglasses and a leather jacket as she left the BBC Radio One Studio after an interview on Oct. 15 in London.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Charlie Hunnam filmed scenes on the set of "Sons Of Anarchy" in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 14. He recently left his role in "Fifty Shades of Grey" due to his intense TV schedule.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Kris and Kylie Jenner were seen walking back to their car after having lunch in Calabasas, Calif., on Oct. 14.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Cara Delevingne was spotted during her photoshoot for DKNY in Times Square, New York City on Oct. 14.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Kate Winslet attended the Mayfair Gala European premiere of "Labor Day" during the 57th BFI London Film Festival at Odeon Leicester Square on Oct. 14. The pregnant star wore a Jennie Packham dress and De Beers jewelry.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Britney Spears was all smiles as she visited Capital FM Radio in London, England on Oct. 14.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Diet Pepsi spokesperson Sofia Vergara flaunted her fandom at a football viewing party held at a friend's house in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 13.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Jessica Simpson and fiance Eric Johnson departed on a flight at LAX airport in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 13.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Snooki and Cheryl Burke went out and about in West Hollywood, Calif., on Oct. 11.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Sandra Bullock arrived for the premiere of her new film "Gravity" at the 57th BFI London Film Festival on Oct. 10.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Khloe Kardashian supported Kenny 'Babyface' Edwards as he received a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on Oct. 10.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    "Grey's Anatomy" actress Sandra Oh stopped by the ABC studios to appear on "Good Morning America" on Oct. 10 in New York City.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Kelly Clarkson attended the American Music Awards Nominees Announcement at BB King's Club in New York City on Oct. 10.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    "Rent" co-stars Rosario Dawson and Taye Diggs attended the Men's Health 25th anniversary celebration at Isola, Mondrian Soho Hotel on Oct. 9 in New York City.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Hayden Panettiere showed off her huge diamond engagement ring as she returned to the Trump Soho Hotel on October 9 in New York City.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Kris Jenner flashed a big smile as she left an office building in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 9, the day after announcing her separation from husband Bruce Jenner.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Tom Hanks and Rita Wilson posed at the European premiere of "Captain Phillips" on the opening night of the 57th BFI London Film Festival at Odeon Leicester Square on Oct. 9 in London.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    A sparkling Kate Hudson shined in a disco ball broken glass dress for a photo shoot in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 8.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Miley Cyrus signed copies of her CD "Bangerz" at Planet Hollywood in New York City Oct. 8.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Lea Michele met Jane Lynch and Matthew Morrison of "Glee" for lunch at the Four Seasons in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 8.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Jessica Alba was seen outside Breakfast Television and the CBC building, promoting her 'The Honest Company' baby products in Toronto on Oct. 8.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Jude Law signed autographs for fans outside the BBC Radio One studios on Oct. 8 in London.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Molly Sims picked up designer fall fashions at T.J.Maxx in West Hollywood, Calif., on Oct. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Abbie Cornish attended the MIPCOM party during MIPCOM 2013 in Cannes, France on Oct. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Stacy Keibler hit the road on the Can-Am Spyder, celebrating with an early birthday ride in the open air in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Khloe Kardashian and Rapper The Game arrived at Tru Night Club in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Zooey Deschanel filmed a scene on the beach for her hit show "The New Girl" in Malibu, Calif., on Oct. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Hilary Swank and her boyfriend Laurent Fleury were seen holding hands after a tennis practice in a local park by the Hudson River in Downtown, Manhattan on Oct. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Jackie Chan and Nicole Kidman attended the opening ceremony of the 10th Huading Awards on Oct. 7 in Macao, China.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Miley Cyrus performs live on NBC's "Today" show in Rockefeller Center on October 7, 2013 in New York City




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Selena Gomez stopped to get some gas before heading to a dance studio in Tarzana, Calif., on Oct. 6.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Keith Urban announced the world premiere of The URBAN Guitar Collection -- debuting live on HSN Nov. 3 -- on Oct. 4 in Tampa, Fla.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Katherine Heigl and husband Josh Kelley looked smitten after lunch at Bubby's restaurant in TriBeCa, NYC, on Oct. 4.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Brad Pitt and Shia LaBeouf filmed their new movie 'Fury' in Oxfordshire, England on October 4.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Kim Kardashian posted a photo on Oct. 4 of her daughter, North, who is almost four months old.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Newly engaged Naya Rivera attended the Latina Magazine 'Hollywood Hot List' party at The Redbury Hotel in Hollywood on Oct. 3.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Controversial celebrity photographer Terry Richardson released a series of risque photos of Miley Cyrus on Oct. 3. In them, Cyrus is seen licking a mirror, smoking, and stripping.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Penelope Cruz stunned at a special screening of "The Counselor" at Odeon West End in London on October 3, just two and a half months after welcoming baby girl Luna.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Christina Milian looked beautiful as she stepped out for dinner in West Hollywood, Oct. 3.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Julianne Moore was honored with a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on Oct. 3 in Los Angeles.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Newlywed Chrissy Teigen, wearing knee-high brown leather boots with a grey top and blue denim hot pants, hailed a taxi in NYC on Oct. 3.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Gwyneth Paltrow filmed a Hugo Boss commercial in downtown Los Angeles on October 3.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Amanda Seyfried and her denim cutoff shorts took Finn for a walk in New York City on October 3.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Cate Blanchett was peach perfection at the New York Film Festival Gala Tribute held in her honor Oct. 2 in New York.